Substance Use Recovery and Symptom Swapping      

a hand blocking the dominoes

Recovery from substance abuse is a complex and multifaceted journey. One less-discussed but equally gripping challenge that can arise during this transition is the development of behavioral addictions, such as exercise addiction and eating disorders. It’s important to note that the DSM-5 does not currently recognize exercise addiction as a standalone disorder, which can further complicate the understanding and treatment of this condition, especially for those in recovery from substance abuse.

These conditions are intricately connected to the brain’s quest for short-term rewards – feelings of acceptance, power, and release. Substance abuse may initially provide this escape from emotion, but as recovery progresses, individuals may find themselves seeking out other avenues to fill the void. This can manifest in the form of love and sex addiction, gambling, or disordered eating behaviors.

The process of “symptom swapping” is not exclusive to eating disorders. It can also occur between substance use disorders and other behavioral addictions, underscoring the deeply intertwined nature of these conditions.

Psychological Factors: Filling the Void

If the deeper underlying trauma driving substance abuse is not adequately addressed during recovery, individuals may turn to other maladaptive coping mechanisms to fill the emotional and psychological voids left by substance cessation. This can lead to the emergence of new presenting issues, such as a fixation on body image or the development of disordered eating patterns.

The core issue, however, is not the behavior itself, but rather the underlying emotions and trauma that drive the need for escape. Individuals may find themselves focusing on aspects like food and exercise as a way to regain a sense of control and power over their lives, which can ultimately reinforce the maladaptive coping mechanism.

The Rise of Exercise Addiction Post-Substance Recovery

For individuals in substance recovery, exercise can become the “drug of choice,” providing a sense of control and power over the difficulties they face. This is rooted in the genetic and learned pathways of escaping negative emotions for short-term benefits, a pattern that is eerily similar to substance abuse.

Exercise, when taken to extremes, can lead to negative health consequences, such as stress from missing a workout, increased pressure on joints, and insufficient recovery time. This fine line between healthy exercise and addiction is crucial to navigate during the recovery process.

When Exercise Addiction Meets Eating Disorders

The interplay between exercise addiction and eating disorders can be particularly challenging for individuals in substance recovery. As exercise becomes the new “escape,” individuals may begin to obsess over food, restricting their diets and having difficulty eating in social situations.

Alarmingly, these obsessive behaviors can sometimes be glorified and praised by well-meaning family members, who may perceive them as a display of “strong willpower.” This reinforcement can further solidify the maladaptive coping mechanism, making it even more difficult to break the cycle.

The Role of Control and Body Image

Drugs and eating disorders serve a similar purpose – they provide a sense of control and escape when life feels overwhelming. By exerting control over their bodies, individuals can find temporary relief from feelings of fear, emptiness, stress, powerlessness, inadequacy, and loneliness.

This need for control and the desire to manage their physical appearance can be a driving force behind the development of exercise addiction and eating disorders during the substance recovery process.

Spotting the Signs: Symptoms and Red Flags

Identifying the warning signs of exercise addiction and eating disorders in individuals recovering from substance abuse is crucial. According to Emily Slager from Walden Behavioral Care, these include:

  1. Irritability, anxiety, or depression when missing a workout
  2. Continuing to exercise when sick, injured, or exhausted
  3. Viewing exercise as a way to “escape”
  4. Workouts starting to impact relationships and other priorities
  5. Redefining happiness around exercise
  6. Continually extending and increasing the duration of workouts
  7. Excessively working out
  8. Exercise losing its element of play and fun

To understand more about exercise addiction, read my post here.

Navigating Recovery: Strategies for Managing Exercise Addiction and Eating Disorders

Effective strategies for managing these conditions involve a multifaceted approach. First and foremost, it is essential to know the signs and symptoms of exercise addiction and eating disorders. Identifying trusted individuals who can provide support, and learning how to ask for help, are also crucial steps.

Seeking professional guidance and support, such as joining free support groups like those offered by the Alliance for Eating Disorders and Project HEAL, can offer invaluable resources and a community of understanding. Additionally, working with professionals who focus on Health at Every Size (HAES) principles can help individuals establish a healthier, more balanced relationship with exercise and food.

The Role of Community and Support Networks

Support groups and community resources can play a vital role in the recovery process, providing a safe space for individuals to process their experiences with others who understand the unique challenges they face. These groups offer the opportunity to connect with peers, share stories, and find strength in the shared journey of overcoming exercise addiction and eating disorders during substance recovery.

Personal Stories: Triumphs and Challenges

Sharing the personal experiences of individuals who have navigated these challenges can offer hope and inspiration to those struggling with the transition from substance recovery to managing exercise addiction and eating disorders.

For example, Betsy Reed from The Guardian writes about her struggle with exercise addiction:

“In 12-step culture you can talk about having a troubled relationship with drugs, alcohol, food, sex, relationships, money, work, shopping and even crime, and people Get It… But exercise? Not so much. People didn’t understand how exercise could be an issue, or they were, by their own admission, jealous, or they failed to grasp the extent of what I was doing with my body.”

She further elaborates, “During the year I was strung out on the gym, I see how strong I was. I also remember how weak I felt, and how many hours I made myself train in the pursuit of getting stronger.”

Additionally, Rachel Moe’s account of facing an eating disorder and maintaining sobriety highlights the complexities of this journey, where she had to “face eating six times a day, while also maintaining sobriety and not diving into exercise and restriction to cope.”

Conclusion: Embracing a Holistic Approach to Recovery

It’s important to note that the DSM-5 does not currently recognize exercise addiction as a standalone disorder, which can further complicate the understanding and treatment of this condition, especially for those in recovery from substance abuse. Addressing all aspects of recovery, including the potential development of exercise addiction and eating disorders, is essential for long-term health and well-being. By taking a comprehensive and holistic approach, individuals can maintain their sobriety and avoid falling into different, but equally debilitating, disorders. This approach not only benefits the individual’s physical and mental health but also helps to ensure the sustainability of their recovery process.

Related Articles

Anorexia in Men: Shattering the Stigma and Unveiling the Truth

Eating disorders like anorexia affect men too, but societal stigma and toxic masculinity often prevent them from seeking help. The pressure to conform to masculine ideals leads to shame, delayed diagnosis, and inadequate treatment. Recognizing the signs and providing non-judgmental support is crucial. Breaking the stigma and providing gender-sensitive care are essential for male recovery.

Read More »

Binge Eating Disorder and Men: An Overlooked Male Eating Disorder

Binge eating disorder (BED) is often overlooked, particularly in men due to societal and cultural factors. Approximately 3.5% of women and 2% of men in the US experience BED, with men facing unique challenges such as gender stereotypes and weight stigma. Binge eating episodes are commonly triggered by emotional distress, and recovery involves developing mindful eating and managing emotional triggers. Early detection and intervention, along with family support and cognitive-behavioral therapy, are crucial for addressing BED in men and creating a more inclusive and supportive environment.

Read More »
Slava Kharitonenkov, MS, RDN
Certified Eating Disorder Specialist
Food is my profound passion, a catalyst that stirs my soul. My personal journey intertwined with food, veering from the pure joy of “bread” as my first word to a disheartening era of fear and rigid routines. It was through this my tumultuous path getting my own support then working in an eating disorder treatment center that I found my purpose.

Slava Kharitonenkov

My Favorite Blogs
Explore Blog Categories

Discover more from MENdED

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading